Basic Trendy

Ellen Greenberg: Murder Or Suicide?

Pic By Daily Mail
Pic By Daily Mail

Who was Ellen Greenberg?

Ellen Greenberg's Death: Parents Believe It Was Murder, Not Suicide | Crime  News
Pic: Oxygen

Ellen was born on June 23rd of 1983. in New York City. Ellen is the daughter of Joshua Greenberg and Sandra Greenberg, who both work in the dental field. Joshua characterizes Ellen as a girly girl who was very energetic. Ellen is characterized as exceptionally kind and a nurturing soul. Because of her nurturing characteristics, Ellen went into teaching, and several of her students idolized her.
Ellen met a man named Sam who worked in the Tv field. Sam was a producer for NBC. After being together for three years, the couple ended up getting engaged. Ellen was pleased with this time in her life. They schemed to have their marriage in August of 2011. Ellen’s dad says that they were thrilled. She had eventually found a man that she adored. He approved of the engagement and schemed to help out with the marriage.

Ellen Was On The Way

On January 26th of 2011, Ellen was on the way to work and spoke to her mum on the cell phone. It was a usual conversation. They chatted about taxes and the snow falling there in Pennsylvania. The snow ended up getting worse, and the school was dismissed early. Ellen assisted all of her students to call their families and made certain everyone had a ride home.

After all of her students were taken off, she went and got some gas and went home. When she got home, the couple hung out for a little while, and then Sam took off to go work out.

The Crime Scene

On his arrival, Sam acknowledged their door was shut. It was rare for her to be home and close the door. The door was not locked as normal it was closed with a swing lock. They only did this at night and never did it in the daytime. Sam texts her and tells her that he is home waiting at the door.

He also says that he is getting annoyed and can not unlock the door. Sam began to concern when Sam got no reaction and went to security to beg them to open the door. The Security worker said to Sam that he could not unlock the door for him because it is against the policy, so Sam decided to break in and have the security worker oversee it.

He Saw Her

When Sam broke the door down, he was stunned. Sam discovered Ellen on the ground of their living room. When Sam saw her, he could tell that she was dead. Ellen’s corpse was leaning against the cabinet, and Sam discovered a neat white towel in her hands. Sam instantly called the police, and the dispatch instructed Sam to begin chest compressions instantly. Sam started CPR but quickly understood a knife was lodged in her, so the dispatch officer instructed him to stop. When EMTs got to the spectacle, they couldn’t do anything to save her. Ellen was declared dead at 6:40 pm.
Right away, the police chose to deal with the case as suicide. At the spectacle, the police discovered freshly cut fruit. There was a strainer with freshly washed blueberries.
They discovered no indication of a break-in or forced entry. Ellen did not have any defense wounds either.
There was no indication on Ellen’s corpse that she had struggled to fight anyone off, and there was no indication of blood outside of the kitchen area. The knife discovered in Ellen only had her DNA on its handle. Since the snow was so prevalent that day, they surveyed the snow for footprints, but nothing was found.

After Death

Before going into the details of Ellen’s corpse, I would say that it may be frightening for some readers. This is a caution.
The day after her demise, the medical examiner stated the autopsy procedure. The medical examiner discovered eight stab wounds to her chest area, and they ranged in depth. Some of the stab wounds only went .2 centimeters deep, while others went 4 inches deep. Ellen also had a two-inch stab wound to her stomach and a two-and-a-half-inch hole on her scalp. Ellen had ten stab wounds to the rear of her neck and eleven bruises on her right arm, abdomen, and right leg. Some of these grazes looked old, and some of them looked like they were more recent. At the end of the autopsy, the medical examiner decreed the case as a homicide.
No one from the police station or the medical examiner’s office reached Ellen’s family about the alteration in the case. The family found out about the change on the news.

A homicide:

Once the case was ruled a murder, the Philidelphia homicide unit decided to step in and investigate the situation. The homicide unit glanced at Sam’s key fob records and traced where he went in the complex. The homicide unit also was eligible to notice that no one unauthorized reached the complex. Sam’s alibi was a match, and he was cleared from the suspect list.
A few days later on, January 29th of 2011, the police declared that even though the medical examiner ruled the case as a homicide, they were still looking at the circumstance as a suicide.
As the inquiry proceeded, the investigators found out that Ellen’s mental health had most probably declined within the last two months of her life. People told that Ellen appeared nervous and anxious about everything. When Ellen was inquired about her emotions, she told people that it was her job. The police brought some teachers in from her school and questioned them. The teachers told the questioners that Ellen appeared stressed out by the employment and did not appear to be any more stressed out with the employment than other teachers.
Ellen’s parents told that Ellen had called them and notified them she wanted to resign from her job. Ellen also asked if she could move back into their home in Harrisburg. Ellen’s parents inquired her if there was anything else causing her to think this way, and she said to her parents that she was just stressed out. Her parents guessed it was very unusual for her to behave like this due to her marriage being a few months away.


Ellen’s parents wanted her to go see a psychiatrist, and she did. Ellen had three visits with her psychiatrist, and it appeared to improve her mood and mental stability. In Ellen’s psychiatrist remarks, the psychiatrist says that Ellen is not suicidal. Ellen was diagnosed with an adjustment disorder and tension. Ellen was prescribed multiple drugs to take, which list suicidal thoughts and tendencies on the symptom lists.
At the time of Ellen’s demise, toxicology reports only have two of the four drugs prescribed to her in her system. No recreational drugs or other prescriptions were discovered. Zoloft, one of the anti-depressants, has been claimed to be the apparent reason for her death. This is due to the symptom of suicidal thoughts and tendencies.
After looking through her phone, they did not discover any indications of suicidal searches or texts.

The argument:

The police were looking at this as a suicide due to the absence of evidence of forced entry. Others contend that this could not have been suicide because she had stab wounds on the back of her neck. Stabbing yourself in the neck is incredibly hard particularly, on the backside of the neck. Research shows that about one to three percent of suicide tries are by stabbings. Another thing people have been contending over is the fact that Ellen stabbed herself numerous times.

The Neuropathologist:

The police decided to reach a neuropathologist to assume whether the stab wounds on the back of her neck broke the spinal cord. If the spinal cord was broken, that would render Ellen paralyzed before the stab wound that murdered her could have been inflicted. The neuropathologist told police that the spinal cord was hit, but the spinal cord was only damaged and not broken. The neuropathologist predicts this made Ellen go numb and could make the impression of Ellen stabbing herself in other areas more reasonable. This would allow Ellen to cause multiple stabs on herself numerous times without pain. If this is authentic, Ellen stabbed herself over 20 times, which is unimaginable.
Medical examiners decided to overturn the case back to suicide after this discovery.

The forensic pathologist:

After the medical examiner overturned the case back to suicide, Ellen’s family decided to buy all pictures and documents from the government and sent them to a forensic pathologist. The forensic pathologist’s name is Cyril West. He is recognized for contesting the single-bullet theory in JFK’s case. When he read the report, he was stunned to find that Ellen had so many stab wounds. Cyril glanced at everything. Cyril told that he could not believe that the police ruled this as suicide.
The family was enthusiastic to get things rolling in the case. They hired a lawyer and a forensic pathologist to speak to the police about opening the case back up. Nothing came out of the conversation. The police refused access to records, and the family and the forensic pathologist were furious about this. The family went and filed for a public record request. The family ultimately got access to the file information. But the family was not authorized to record or take notes about anything they were shown.
A retired police veteran, Tom Brennen, offered to operate the Ellen Greenberg case for free outside of the government. He took a look at the files and told that it is not a done deal when someone does not have any defense wounds. It does not mean that it is suicide. The veteran also knew a case like this before. The veteran told that if this case was a homicide, it is called a blitz attack. This is where the killer attacks the victim with such surprise, and the assault is so quick that the victim hardly sees it coming.
A homicide prosecutor named Guy De Andrea begged to see the whole case file. When he looked into the file, he understood that there was not a neuropathology report. He asked the regional police station and the medical examiner where it was, and they told it was either misplaced or did not exist. They also discovered out that the medical examiner didn’t even have a neuropathologist staffed there at the time.
Tom Brennen found out that the medical examiner had a piece of Ellen’s spinal cord at the office. Tom got in connection with a forensic pathologist to analyze the spinal cord of Ellen Greenberg. The forensic pathologist concluded something unusual than the first supposed pathologist. The forensic pathologist concluded that one of the stab wounds penetrated Ellen’s cranial cavity and broke the cranial nerves and brain. As a result of this, Ellen would have been severely impaired or lost consciousness and would encounter horrible pain. This forensic pathologist also assumed that there was an indication of strangulation.


As people were recruited, Henry Lee joined the team. Henry Lee has been glimpsed in O.J. Simpson’s killing trial. He surveyed Ellen’s case and told that the number and kinds of wounds and bloodstain patterns were incompatible with suicide and were consistent in a homicide. This leaves us with a question… How did the door get locked from the inside if it was a homicide?
Tom indicated there were many videos on youtube demonstrating how to utilize the swing lock from the outside. Another research has shown that most suicides involving stab wounds are under the clothes and not above like Ellen’s were.
The police had told the public that Ellen’s cell phone and computer were neat of any red flags. Other experts told that the searches ‘quick suicide’, ‘painless suicide’ and ‘suicide methods’ were discovered on her laptop.
In 2019, the family filed a civil lawsuit against the Philadelphia medical examiner’s office and the pathologist. They were wishing to get the medical examiners to alter the ruling from undetermined to homicide. To this day, the attorneys and other people on their team still accept that the circumstance is impossible. Other outcomes have been made. They discovered that two different knives inflicted the wounds. One is serrated, and the other being smooth. There was only one knife discovered, which was the one inside of her at the time.


Sam has never done any interviews. He does not come out to the public. In 2020 some more evidence about Sam was published including, how Sam behaved at the scene. Sam’s story was that when he was kicking down the door, the security man was with him. Phil, the security man, told that Phil never was with Sam. Phil also said the police that Sam was not wearing sneakers that day. He was wearing boots. This makes no sense because he was seemingly coming from the gym. Sam had also called two other numbers before calling 9–1–1. He called his parents and his uncle, which was a lawyer. Both his parents and his uncle were on their way to the spectacle before 9–1–1 was even called. The dispatch officer also told that during the call, Sam was calm. The dispatch also reported that when Sam was inquired to perform CPR, he inquired, ‘do I have to?’ Sam knew there was a knife inside Ellen’s chest. Sam tells the dispatch that she possibly fell on it.
Another discover indicates that there was little to no blood at the crime spectacle. This begs the question if someone had attempted to clean the spectacle. There was no luminol test conducted.
Recently it was declared to the public that the door was not kicked down. The door had little to no defect. The only damage was discovered on the lock, and one of the screws was skipping. This screw was never glimpsed again. Sam’s family come back to the crime spectacle the day after and collected Sam’s equipment and Ellen’s laptop and cellphone.

Article By Tatiana Santana, A Famous Writer From Medium

Source: The Bizzare Death Of Ellen

Share if you like it